First-time home buyer insurance
Nobody explains a homeowners policy to you before you are asked to buy one. Here are the six parts of it, what each one actually does, and the three decisions that matter.
- Monday – Friday: 6:00 AM – 7:00 PM Pacific Time9:00 AM – 10:00 PM Eastern Time
- Saturday: 6:00 AM – 5:00 PM Pacific Time9:00 AM – 8:00 PM Eastern Time
Homeowners quotes by phone are not available in California, Florida or New York. Send your details on the form below and someone will follow up.
Prefer to send it in writing? Scroll down →The three decisions that matter most on your first policy
- 1
The dwelling limit — rebuild cost, not purchase price
This is the number everything else keys off. It should be what rebuilding the house would cost today, which is not what you paid, because the price included the land. On an older house, ask about ordinance and law coverage too: rebuilding to current code can cost more than rebuilding what was there. Extended replacement cost adds a cushion above the limit for when a whole street rebuilds at once and prices move.
- 2
Replacement cost or actual cash value, on contents and on the roof
Replacement cost pays for a comparable new item. Actual cash value deducts depreciation first. On a six-year-old sofa that difference is annoying; on a fifteen-year-old roof it is most of the roof. Ask which basis applies to personal property and which applies to the roof, and get both answers on the declaration page rather than in conversation.
- 3
The deductible — what you are actually buying with the savings
A higher deductible lowers the premium, and the question is whether you could write that check this month without borrowing. Watch for a second deductible: coastal policies often carry a separate percentage deductible for named storms, and some policies carry a separate wind-and-hail deductible inland. A percentage of the dwelling limit is a larger number than it looks.
The six parts of a homeowners policy
Dwelling covers the house and what is attached to it. Other structures covers the detached garage, shed and fence, usually at a percentage of the dwelling limit. Personal property covers your belongings, on and away from the premises. Loss of use pays the added cost of living elsewhere while a covered loss makes the house unlivable. Personal liability responds when someone is hurt or their property is damaged and you are responsible, including the cost of defending the claim. Medical payments to others covers minor guest medical costs without arguing about fault. Every quote you compare is a different arrangement of those six.
What is not in there, and has to be bought separately
Flood is excluded from every standard policy and comes from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood market — and a good share of flood claims happen outside mapped high-risk zones. Earthquake is excluded and bought separately, usually with a percentage deductible. Sewer and drain backup is normally an endorsement rather than base coverage, and it is what answers when a storm pushes a municipal line into a finished basement. Termite and other insect damage is never covered. Ordinary wear is never covered.
The sub-limits that catch first-time buyers out
Jewelry, watches, firearms, cash, silverware, bicycles, cameras and instruments all carry internal limits well below the overall personal property limit, and several are limited for theft specifically. An engagement ring is the classic example: covered, but to a figure far below what it cost. Scheduling the individual item fixes it and is inexpensive. Make the list before the policy starts, not after something goes missing.
Buying your auto at the same time
Most carriers write home and auto together and discount both. Your first house is also the moment your auto policy address changes, so the work is happening anyway. Aligning the two renewal dates means you review everything once a year instead of twice.
Questions to ask on your first quote call
Any of these is a fair question and the answers should be specific.
- What rebuild cost per square foot does this dwelling limit assume?
- Is extended or guaranteed replacement cost available, and what is the cushion?
- Is personal property on replacement cost or actual cash value?
- How does the policy pay a roof claim — replacement cost, or depreciated by age?
- Is there a second deductible for wind, hail or named storms?
- Is water backup included, and at what limit?
- What are the sub-limits for jewelry, bicycles and electronics?
- Is ordinance and law coverage included for an older house?
- What is the multi-policy discount if I move my auto across?
You can bundle home and auto on the same call
Most carriers write home and auto together and apply a multi-policy discount to both when they do. Renters and auto bundle the same way, so you do not have to own the place to get the credit. Ask what the discount comes to on each policy before you decide, and ask to line the two renewal dates up so you review everything once a year instead of twice.
Frequently asked questions
How much homeowners insurance does a first-time buyer need?
Enough dwelling coverage to rebuild the house at today’s costs, personal property set against what you actually own rather than a default percentage, and a liability limit you are comfortable with. The lender’s minimum is a floor, not a recommendation.
What is the difference between replacement cost and actual cash value?
Replacement cost pays to replace an item without deducting for age and wear. Actual cash value deducts depreciation first. The difference shows up most sharply on roofs and on older contents.
Does homeowners insurance cover flood?
No. Flood is excluded from every standard policy and is bought separately. A large share of flood claims come from outside mapped high-risk zones, so the flood map alone is not the whole answer.
Is my engagement ring covered?
To a sub-limit, which on most policies is far below what a ring costs — and theft is often limited more tightly still. Scheduling the ring individually is the fix, and it is inexpensive.
What is loss of use?
It pays the added cost of living somewhere else while a covered loss makes the house uninhabitable — a hotel, a short-term rental, meals above what you would normally spend. It is one of the most used parts of the policy and one of the least discussed.
Request a homeowners quote
Prefer the phone? Call 866-347-8683 instead. Or send your details below and someone will follow up.
Get the small-business insurance newsletter
Plain-English coverage tips, comparisons, and offers — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.