Colorado homeowners insurance
Hail files most of the claims on Colorado homes and wildfire decides whether a carrier will write them. Both of those answers live in the fine print of the roof and dwelling terms.
- Monday – Friday: 6:00 AM – 7:00 PM Pacific Time9:00 AM – 10:00 PM Eastern Time
- Saturday: 6:00 AM – 5:00 PM Pacific Time9:00 AM – 8:00 PM Eastern Time
Three reasons to look closely at a Colorado home policy
- 1
The roof terms matter more than the premium
Colorado takes more damaging hail than almost anywhere else, and carriers responded by changing how roofs pay rather than by refusing to write them. Many Colorado policies now settle roof claims on an actual cash value schedule keyed to the age of the roof, and some carry a separate, higher wind-and-hail deductible. On a fifteen-year-old roof the gap between ACV and replacement cost can be most of the new roof. Ask which applies and get it on the declaration page.
- 2
The Marshall Fire was an underinsurance event, not just a fire
More than a thousand homes burned in a single December afternoon in Boulder County, and the lesson owners drew was about dwelling limits. When an entire subdivision rebuilds at once, labor and materials cost more than any estimate assumed. Extended or guaranteed replacement cost is the endorsement that answers it, and it is worth asking for by name rather than hoping it is in there.
- 3
Colorado now has a FAIR plan for homes nobody will write
The state created a Fair Access to Insurance Requirements plan as a last-resort market for property owners who cannot find coverage in the standard market, largely because of wildfire exposure. It exists as a backstop, not as a first stop — the admitted market and the surplus lines market both come first, and mitigation work is what usually keeps you out of it.
Wildfire scoring, and what actually changes a score
Carriers rate the individual parcel: slope, vegetation, engine access, roof material, and what sits in the first five feet around the walls. In the foothills from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs two houses on the same street can be priced differently. Clearing that five feet, moving firewood off the deck, screening vents, replacing a wood shake roof and limbing trees back from the roofline are the changes that most often move an answer — and under Colorado law insurers are required to tell you about the mitigation discounts available.
Water, backup and the finished basement
Burst supply lines, failed water heaters and washing machine hoses produce more Colorado claims than fire. Sewer and drain backup is normally an endorsement rather than base coverage, and it is what answers when a storm pushes a municipal line into a finished basement. Flood is excluded entirely, which matters below burn scars where a July thunderstorm moves debris down a slope that used to hold it.
Insure to rebuild, not to the sale price
The dwelling limit should reflect what rebuilding would cost with today’s Front Range labor and materials, which is not the market value and not the county assessment. Ask what per-square-foot figure the quote assumes, ask what the extended replacement cushion is as a percentage, and ask whether ordinance and law coverage is included for bringing an older house up to current code during a rebuild.
What the underwriter will ask about your house
- Year built, square footage, and the year the roof was last replaced
- Roof material — impact-resistant shingle, standard shingle, metal, tile or wood shake
- Whether the roof carries a Class 4 impact rating, which often earns a discount
- Age of the electrical panel, the furnace and the water heater
- Distance to the nearest hydrant and staffed fire station
- Defensible space: what is within five feet of the walls, and where firewood is stacked
- Whether the basement is finished, and whether there is a backflow valve
- Any dog, trampoline, pool or hot tub on the property
Frequently asked questions
Why is my Colorado roof claim paying less than a new roof costs?
Many Colorado policies settle older roofs on an actual cash value schedule, which pays depreciated worth rather than replacement cost. It is a term in the policy rather than a claim decision, which is why it needs checking before a hailstorm rather than after.
Does an impact-resistant roof lower my premium?
A Class 4 impact-rated roof commonly earns a discount in Colorado, and it also survives hail that would total a standard shingle. Ask what the credit is before you re-roof, since it can change the math on the upgrade.
What is extended replacement cost and do I need it?
It adds a stated cushion above your dwelling limit so a rebuild can exceed the estimate without coming out of your pocket. After the Marshall Fire a lot of Colorado owners concluded the answer was yes.
What if no carrier will write my foothills house?
The surplus lines market handles a great deal of this business, and Colorado also created a FAIR plan as a last-resort market. Mitigation work is usually what keeps a property in the standard market in the first place.
Request your Colorado quote
Prefer the phone? Call 866-347-8683 instead. Or send your details below.
Get the small-business insurance newsletter
Plain-English coverage tips, comparisons, and offers — no spam, unsubscribe anytime.